digitalwellbeing.orgHow to thrive in our hyper-connected world

Are we underestimating digital media harm?

Question: Are we underestimating digital media harm?
Answer: It depends on how you cut the data.

The debate continues to rage in a new slingshot statistical fight between researchers.

In the blue corner, we have University of Oxford researchers Amy Orben and Andrew Przybylski who have published research in the influential journal Nature using an advanced correlational analysis called specification curve analysis (SCA) with large US survey datasets (n = 355,358) to show that social media use is no more linked to wellbeing than eating potatoes.

the association of well-being with regularly eating potatoes was nearly as negative as the association with technology use (0.9x, YRBS) and wearing glasses was more negatively associated with well-being (1.5x, MCS).

Amy Orben and Andrew Przybylski 2019

YRBS = Youth Risk and Behaviour Survey
MCS = Millennium Cohort Study

In the red corner, we have another group of influential psychologists – Jean Twenge, Jonathan Haidt, Thomas Joiner and William Keith Campbell who have now recut and re-analysed the data and published their analysis in the same journal to demonstrate how similar correlational analyses can be used to show that social media use is more linked to wellbeing than taking heroin – for girls.

One could just as easily conclude that social media use is more important for well-being than hard drug use, exercise and obesity… For girls, social media use is far more important than exercise, or even than heroin use.

Jean Twenge, Jonathan Haidt, Thomas Joiner and William Keith Campbell 2020

As you’d guess, the comparison between heroin and social media use for girls has garnered media attention and produced a minor storm in a Twitter-cup, and prompted a response from the social-media-is-as-harmful-as-potatoes camp.

Lies, damned lies and statistics

Beyond the take-out that there are lies, damned lies and statistics – especially correlation-does-not-mean-causation statistics, what can we learn from this social media and potatoes vs heroin debate?

First, research like this needs to be understood in the context of the researchers’ previous research and points of view. Both the blue and red corners are presenting data that supports existing positions. This doesn’t make it wrong, but contextualising it within a body of research helps interpretation.

How, not how much

Second, this research perhaps shows the limits of statistical squiggle-babble squabbles about associations between loosely and variably defined variables. Until we understand the ‘how’, the ‘how much’ may be of limited value. What I think we need more granular research on the potential causal mechanisms the may – or may not – underpin any association between aspects of wellbeing outcomes and specific technology use.

Written by
Dr Paul Marsden
Join the discussion

  • Please note that when ordering this service, you should not wait for a quick and effective result, high-quality work, for which you can be sure, is performed for three to twelve months. The best website promotion will help you to implement the company SEO expert, which specializes in SEO promotion and other services for the perfect operation of specialized web pages, for more information, you can find on the official page at the specified link

  • This can be either a positive influence or a negative one. Children can learn something useful, but they can also fall under the influence of scammers. Ask them what they do and who they correspond with. By the way, now you can easily get text messages from another phone sent to mine, there are whole instructions on how to do this

  • This useful source will allow you to order whatever paper you need. Forget about difficult moments when you didn’t have time to write your essays. Now you can delegate your papers quickly.

  • Hello! Thank you for this article! I think that it’s really important to talk about such things. Anybody else has that eerie feeling of being into social media so much? It has become a lifestyle, a life choice. It’s like you don’t realize it is shaping your life already, keeping you from seeing what truly matters in your life. I don’t like that feeling that I am being a slave to these things. I better exercise caution and self-control.

  • I know personally when the internet goes down for more than an afternoon – I feel like I’m missing something, and the hours can really drag. But I’ve never found that those feelings didn’t subside after a day or two- and then I just turn my attention to more traditional things like books, tv, and movies – (and I actually find my attention span for engaging with those things increases)

    • If you want to execute the finest website marketing, you should choose an SEO expert business that focuses on SEO promotion and other services for the smooth running of niche websites. Click here to visit the official site for more details.

  • The writer first asks for the topic and the requirements to the student in the first place and take WEBSITE of time to understand it by themselves, in order to explain it deeply to the students. Here, the purpose is to explain the difficult criteria attached with the essays that has to be fulfilled as per the rubrics

  • I gained a lot of knowledge from reading your site, and if you want to have more interesting experiences, you should educate yourself on previous video games. Playing with you in the past is something I am looking forward to!

Digital wellbeing covers the latest scientific research on the impact of digital technology on human wellbeing. Curated by psychologist Dr. Paul Marsden (@marsattacks). Sponsored by WPP agency SYZYGY.