digitalwellbeing.orgHow to thrive in our hyper-connected world

The Sense in the (Anti) F-Commerce Rant

So we think f-commerce (e-commerce with Facebook) is a really good idea when you use Facebook as an e-commerce-enabled fan management platform designed to drive fan loyalty and activate fan advocacy through fan-firsts, fan-exclusives and fan-merchandise sold in a Facebook fan-store.

But not everyone agrees that f-commerce is a good idea.  Put your profanity filters on and head over to the smart and articulate ecompunk blog to see a demolition job, with attitude, on f-commerce from Magento guru Dr Roman Zenner (BTW it’s worth subscribing to the ecompunk blog; along with exciting commerce and get elastic, it’s the best source of e-commerce insight and inspiration out there).

The anti f-commerce argument goes something like this;

  • Facebook is an application, and applications are purposive, they are for something – the Facebook app is for exchanging with friends
  • You can use apps to do other things than for what they’re for (say write a letter using Microsoft Excel, or set up a shop with Facebook), but the result is likely to be sup-optimal for two reasons
    • 1) that’s not what the app was designed for
    • 2) people will ignore the extra functionality, because that’s not what they’re using the app for (exchanging with friends).  To pursue the analogy, setting up shop on Facebook is like adding a letter template to Excel – pointless.

Roman adds that of course there’s more to f-commerce than setting up shop in Facebook (you can integrate your e-commerce site with Facebook, or simply use Facebook as a blog to drive e-commerce traffic).  But integrating your external e-commerce site with Facebook to enable automatic sharing of what customers do on your site or elective sharing of stuff they like is crass; it creates social spam and is only likely to attract the desperate, lonely and compulsive. No future in it.

Well, we agree wholeheartedly with Roman – but with three caveats (two of which Roman makes himself)

  • 1) Yes, Facebook is an application for exchanging with friends, but Facebook has evolved from application to application platform – and has seen success (and profits) as an e-commerce enabled application platform for online gaming.  So there’s precedent for Facebook e-commerce apps.
  • 2) Yes, Facebook is a sub-optimal platform for running e-commerce apps, but it’s a cost-effective ‘second-screen’ for catering to fans, and as a fan-channel – a Facebook fan-store to drive fan loyalty and advocacy makes sense
  • 3) Yes, integrating e-commerce sites with Facebook can create social spam, but it can also help you learn about your customers, and help your customers shop smarter – by learning from each other

So don’t throw the f-commerce baby out with the strategy-free Facebook bathwater. F-commerce makes sense when you use Facebook for fan management and/or customer insight…  That, from an f-commerce perspective, is what Facebook is for.

Written by
Dr Paul Marsden
Join the discussion

digitalwellbeing.org

digitalwellbeing.org

Digital wellbeing covers the latest scientific research on the impact of digital technology on human wellbeing. Curated by psychologist Dr. Paul Marsden (@marsattacks). Sponsored by WPP agency SYZYGY.